And do you have any guesses as to who played whom?

But my mom says "Your identity is your most valuable possesion."

Gotta tell you, that was a pretty scary experience. I don't ever want to go back to Arkham!

A big hearty THANKS to all the superheroes and members who bravely rescued us.

And do you have any guesses as to who played whom?

I suspect Poison Ivy was either Lady A or Bookwyrm, but I'm likely very wrong...

Also Ben 10 was either PA, or someone else hoping we would think it's PA

And the Green Hornet- Stargazer or GlimGlum?

I'm probably very wrong on all of these actually You guys were smart in not changing the user names... makes it much harder to figure out

Captain America= Cor?

Aye, many thanks to all the heroes and members who helped spring us out of there!!

Apparently I got the better end of the deal in Arkham... they stuck me in a large room with Killer Croc, who incidentally, loves playing cards. Good thing I had some on hand.

Now excuse me, I need to go take a hot shower. The room was partially flooded and I'm not completely sure if it was black or greenish...

P.S, Natasha Romanoff you are the BEST! And Tony, Thor and Cap as well, I suppose.

Welcome back, Mods! So glad you're all safe.

I'm with Wolfloversk in guessing Ben 10 was Princess Anna.
Lady A may have been Black Widow. Or was it PrinceCor, given his post above?
Pattertwig's Pal may have been Thor?
I also think Mrs. Incredible was ramagut. Not too sure about everyone else.
Are there any guesses about who was Joker?
Are we going to be told?

Thank you all so much for rescuing us!
I'm really glad it didn't last longer - it was a scary experience, not least by not knowing anything about how long it might last.

So when you turned up and told us that we were safe - it was perhaps the best moment of my life. I'm so grateful. You really are the best

Guesses:
Thor - Mountie
Captain America - Mountie? Maybe?
Ironman - Cor
Poison Ivy - Lady A
The Joker - No clue. Booky perhaps?
Oracle - No idea. I was stumped all day. xD Although thinking about it, perhaps Malkah?
Violet and Dash - Djaq and Flam?

I myself was

Spoiler

Luna Lovegood, Dean Winchester, and Sherlock. I apologize for Sherlock's rudeness.

Just for the record, I portrayed the Ninth Doctor, although somebody who was a moderator said I sounded like the Tenth Doctor.

Thanks to everyone who helped rescue us. I've only been a moderator for 3 April First and have been in dangerous situations for 2 off them. I want a raise.

Are we going to be told?

Eventually, we want to give people plenty of time to guess. Maybe a week?

Home sweet home!

Are you going to be told? Hmmm....hmmm....maybe. I'm just trying not to start quizzing you all on why you guess as you do. I suppose every now and then I need to hide the analytical side.

Not too confident about all my guesses, but...

Something in Iron Man's profile made me think he might be Booky.

I was thinking Malkah might be either Oracle or Captain America.

Cor might be Black Widow.

Wren is probably Poison Ivy.

And Mountie might be Thor. And/or Black Widow, if Cor isn't her. I also suspected she might be Iron Man and Cap at times... She's just such a good character actress, it's hard to say.

Also, Harley Quinn was probably Wren or Booky.

The Joker completely stumped me. I assumed at first, just from the nature of the character, that it would be Wren or Booky. But it didn't sound like either of them, for some reason. Either way, major props to whoever The Joker was.

I'm going to take a stab in the dark and say Gymfan was Lois Lane. And that Jack-Jack was EtJ.

EDIT: I forgot to mention my guess of Princess Anna being Ben 10!

~Riella

Phew! Thanks to those who masterminded the mission and got us out of there! I can't say I enjoyed my time of captivity, but we have returned unscathed... okay, scathed. Very scathed. But mostly hungry.

(Props if you caught the BBC Robin Hood reference. )

I'm so enjoying reading everyone's guesses, but as for the accuracy of them, my lips are currently sealed. However, thanks to everyone who made this April Fool's such a success! It was extremely fun and once again I'm reminded why this is one of the coolest forums on earth. April Fool's Day is one of my favorite days of the year because of NarniaWeb, and it was so amazing and hilarious to get to spend it with you! Thanks so much for the fun--I can't wait for next year!

I've only been a moderator for 3 April First and have been in dangerous situations for 2 off them. I want a raise.

I heartily concur. "There's not a lot of money in moderating. I just work for Vizzinni to pay the bills."

Oh, our dear moddies are back!!! *dabs eyes with hanky and gives the mods hot cocoa* We missed you!! We were so worried!!! And just after MAD, too! It's like it was planned and everything!!
But we're glad you're back

Here are my guesses:

Thor - Mountie
Ironman - Cor
Miss Martian - stargazer
Catwoman - Lady Arwen? Gymfan15? starkat?
Black Widow - malkah?
Captain America - flambeau
Dash - Djaq?
Violet - Daughter of the King? or Pattertwigs Pal?
Edna Mode - Meltintalle?
Samwise the Brave - Jo
Green Lantern - Shastastwin?
Lois Lane - Valia?
Poison Ivy - Bookwyrm?
Elastagirl - for some reason, I'm guessing Fantasia?
The duo of supermouse and that girl.... for some reason, I'm going to guess stardf29 and Varna. Not sure why; no harm in guessing.
Ben10 - Princess Anna

Not sure about the rest! You guys really stumped us this year. I might edit this later if I have another guess