I would take Eustace's. Not only did he get to sail to the end of the world live as a dragon (FLYING!!!!), meet Puddleglum, travel to the north of the world, travel to the bottom of the world, but he also got to see the end of the world, and participate in the battle thereof.

Oooh, good question, and a hard one. *ponders* I think I would choose Digory. To have the experience of seeing the creation of Narnia I think would top just about everything else. And then Digory gets the added bonus of building the wardrobe and housing four kids who find Narnia again by wandering through that wardrobe.
And he gets to fly too, on Fledge.

Yes, a very good question. I think I'd be Edmund. Not that I would want to betray my brother and sisters, but once Edmund turns good he does a pretty good job. He gets to fight in the battles, without having the ultimate responsibility that Peter has. He grows up to be a capable and confident king. He gets to live in Narnia and have a good life there for many years. Aslan congratulates him in PC. Then he gets to sail to the Eastern end of the Narnian world, even if he has to share a room with Eustace. Finally he goes to Aslan's Country with the others.

I agree with King_Erlian, I think I have to go with Edmund. Not because I'd want to hang out with the White Witch or be the traitor, but because I think Edmund's journey is one that is the deepest turn-around. True, all the characters have that arc and grow, but Edmund becomes something far better than what he was before. We all have our faults, but to learn and grow and become someone far deeper and improved, what could be more thrilling?

For me, it is so very difficult to choose between Eustace and Lucy. Lucy had the greatest thrill of the unknown out of the Pevensies, Eustace, and Jill, I think. The others all knew about Narnia before they got there, but Lucy was literally living in our world, the "real world", and suddenly found herself in another one. That feeling would have been extraordinary. She also got to live for quite a while in Narnia as a queen, got to meet Shasta and Aravis, had many close encounters with Aslan, and sailed on the Dawn Treader. But I love the Silver Chair, and Eustace got to sail on the Dawn Treader and go on that journey where I feel he, Jill, and Puddleglum built such a deep friendship.

It's tough. I think Lucy really had it better, living as a queen in Narnia all that time must have been wonderful, and the quest to save Prince Rilian was full of hardship. But in the end, I think I'd sooner choose Eustace. He was a hero to Prince Rilian and King Tirian, which is pretty cool.

Good thread! It's a bit hard, as, when reading the books, I kind of put myself in the characters shoes in order to relate to them, but I did not do the same while on the adventure. I imagined what it would be like for them, but I didn't replace myself with them, if you understand what I mean.

I think Eustace would be my pick. He had the opportunity to adventure into Narnia, whether he liked it or not, and then meet Aslan. I think his experience in the world of Narnia is really interesting, with the whole maritime theme running through the book. Additionally, there's this sense of hope for Eustace at the end of the world, when Aslan tells Edmund and Lucy that they will not be returning. There's this wonderful feeling of belonging experienced by Eustace, that he finally is part of this world now, is going to be here in the future, and is more than a fifth wheel. (I mean, the fact he was in Narnia showed Aslan called him, etc, but I don't think he realized that immediately, and so realizing it was a really meaningful thing.) And then he has the opportunity to introduce another character to Narnia and go there a second time for an independent journey of his own. He has a really thorough experience of Narnia, I think, and it's probably the one I'd like best.

I actually would want my own unique adventure in Narnia - but I chose Lucy. She sees Aslan the most - and Aslan is Narnia.

I had to choose Jill. Sometimes--no, a lot of the time--though I know I have important things to do, I still get quarrelsome. I still argue when I'm tired and hungry, like she does. But she manages to prevail in the end, and I hope I can too.

Lucy, no doubt about it. I love her character, her sweetness and good temper and I think the two of us would get along very well. Also she has a great ability to make friends with others and I think that would really make things good for the both of us

Jill because I can relate to her.

Queen Lucy. I love her Narnian experiences, and her sweet faith always inspires me. Didn't she get into Narnia more than any of the others (counting her brief visits through the wardrobe before all four of them got in?) And to sail to the world's end on the Dawn Treader... ooh! Yes, I'd want to be Lucy

I think I'd want to be Lucy.

Not just for the fact that she spends the most time in Narnia, and I see several good points about how Edmund and Eustace and Jill have more obvious character arcs, but Lucy faces the doubt of the others and stands firm. That's the character trait in myself that I'd want to see 'improved' if you will.

I voted Polly, who watched a world being created.
I'd also wish to experience what Jill did; she was taken from an unhappy situation where she was a powerless victim, and became competent and valiant.

I'd want to have an experience like Lucy. For her, even though she had faults, had rather friendly encounters with Aslan and the other Narnians. I'd like to meet Aslan a lot and have tea with Tumnus.