Lucy - nice list because she's Lucy and doesn't have a mean bone in her body.

Mr. Beaver - naughty list because he knew that the four humans were from a completely different universe, yet acted absolutely shocked when they didn't know about the prophecies.

Glozelle - nice list for ridding us of Miraz (ok, kind of joking about this one). 

Great thread idea!

Edmund- Naughty... at least for the first few chapters of LWW.

Trumpkin- Naughty, for not believing in lions... especially THE lion.

Trufflehunter- Nice, because.... seriously, what's not to like about a loyal badger with a sense of hospitality?

Nikabrik- naughty for losing faith and bringing in evil creatures 

Puddleglum- nice for remaining loyal in tough circumstances 

The Owls in SC - nice, because they were prepared to help Jill and Eustace, and to carry them part of the way

The mice in LB - nice because they helped Tirian by feeding him when he was tied up, even though they were afraid

The schoolboys in PC - naughty because they tormented their teacher (and got turned into pigs)

Nice List

• Aravis - she may be arrogant but in the end, she recognizes her errors and corrects her immature behavior
• Shasta - he has his own attitude problems but, he displays honor and courage when other wouldn't (namely Bree)
• Hwin - she is gentle and compassionate and tries to encourages those around her

Naughty List

• Jadis - she took over Narnia and left it in eternal winter and she killed Aslan
• Rabadash - he has ego problems and does not appear to be apologetic about his attitude and ego

@narnianrose I like your examples, especially those who learned to be better and turned away from their past actions and attitudes. 

In this category are the obvious ones- Edmund, Eustace, and even Trumpkin (who learned to believe).

Wow. You've all had great ones. Let's see if I could think of any.

Lord Drinian- Nice for being there for Caspian after Caspian have lost his wife and son.

Jewel- Nice for a being a friend who sticks around even when things got out of hand.

Rabadash- Naughty for being cruel and arrogant, not to mention all he could ever think about is how he wants to marry Susan.

Emeth- Nice because he's not after some higher promotion. He seeks a higher power, and while claiming to serve Tash, he was actually serving Aslan.

Rishda- Naughty for calling on gods he doesn't believe in and manipulation.

What a great thread idea @jasminetarkheena, and I think it will bring up some interesting thought and conversation.

Uncle Andrew- Very naughty, he is a self-centered, power-hungry old man who cannot control himself.

Digory- Nice, yes, he messed up, and defiantly made some very serious mistakes, but he came about in the end, and was redeemed (same as me...).

Reepicheep-   Very Nice. He was a brave, valiant warrior and knight, who, though maybe a bit over-zealous at times, was a truly noble creature.

Child of the King: SonofStone

P.S. It has been a while, and I am so glad to be back active on NarniaWeb again!

Nice-

Professor Digory Kirke

Polly Plummer

Peter Pevensie

Susan Pevensie

Edmund Pevensie

Lucy Pevensie

Eustace Scrubb

Jill Pole

King Frank I

Queen Helen

King Col I

Olvin

King Gale

Moonwood

Queen Swanwhite

Mr. Tumnus

Mr. Beaver

Mrs. Beaver

The Fox

Squirrel Family

Two Leopards

Giant Rumblebuffin

Shasta/Prince Cor

Prince Corin

King Lune

Aravis Tarkheena

Bree

Hwin

Sallowpad

Thornbolt

The Hermit of the Southern March

Prince Caspian

Nurse

Doctor Cornelius

Trufflehunter

Trumpkin

Pattertwig

Glenstorm

Giant Wimbleweather

Reepicheep

Gwendolen

School Mistress

Lord Drinian

Rhince

Rynelf

Pittencream

Lord Bern

Coriakin

Dufflepods

Lord Rhoop

Ramandu

Ramandu's Daughter

Lord Mavramorn

Lord Revilian

Lord Argoz

Prince Rilian

Puddleglum

Glimfeather

Cloudbirth

Mullugutherum

Golg

King Tirian

Jewel

Roonwit

Puzzle

Squirrels

Mice

Boar

Bear

Dogs

Poggin

Farsight

Emeth

Naughty-

Uncle Andrew

Queen Jadis

The Dwarf

Maugrim/Fenris Ulf

Wolves

Trees on the White Witch's side

The Tisroc

Prince Rabadash

Anradin Tarkaan

Ahoshta

Lasaraleen Tarkheena

Corradin Tarkaan of Castle Tormunt

Azrooh Tarkaan

Ilgamuth Tarkaan of the Twisted Lip

Chlamash Tarkaan

King Miraz

Queen Prunaprismia

Lord Glozelle

Lord Sospesian

Nikabrik

The hag

The warewolf

Pug

Taks

Slave Traders

Governor Gumpas

The Lady of the Green Kirtle

Rock Giants

Giant-King of Harfang

Giant-Queen of Harfang

Shift

Rishda Tarkaan

Ginger

Griffle

Diggle

Slinkey

Wraggle

I'm sure you all know that Christmas is not far away, so we could still have the discussion about which Narnia character would be on the naughty or nice list.