Now, why would Lucy have a candle lit at night when she's supposed to be asleep?

I'll agree with Dinode, although she seemed to be considering something very carefully before she got up--possibly because she was questioning herself as to whether she might've possibly made up Narnia after all, and only just then worked up the nerve.

And I can name 4 people who got into Narnia while trying, Shasta, Aravis, Bree, and Hwin.

Heeheehee. XD Very true.

And I can name 4 people who got into Narnia while trying, Shasta, Aravis, Bree, and Hwin.

Good point, It's kind of a loophole I suppose.

Not really a loophole, is it? They were not coming from a different world to enter Narnia's world - they were born in Narnia's world and just crossed a border.

Not really a loophole, is it? They were not coming from a different world to enter Narnia's world - they were born in Narnia's world and just crossed a border.

No, not a loophole in the true sense of the word I suppose, I just was agreeing that the rule didn't apply to them .