Forum

Share:
Notifications
Clear all

[Closed] Special Feature: Louisa May Alcott

Page 1 / 2
Aslanisthebest
(@aslanisthebest)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

Here we go with a special feature for a very special author, to me at least. :)

Louisa May Alcott has such a pleasant way with words that make nearly all her works very agreeable to read. Of course, there are a few stories that there's some over-exaggeration over the loveliness, purity, character etc of the main character but it only happens in the minority of times. ;))

Recently I've been trying to read all of her works, and I'm about 75% there, having read nearly all of her novels and plowing away at the 5 or so short-story books there are. But, without much further ado, her books:

(Because there are a lot of short-story books, I'll just name the more popular or so ones. :) )

SPOILER WARNING!

The Inheritance (1849, unpublished until 1997)-- Believed to be her first one. The plot is about Edith, a half-Italian lass, who is believed to be only a common girl who was related to her uncle (?) but in the end, happens to be the heir to all the riches of the cousins she's living with. (This one was written when Louisa May Alcott was younger, and there are a lot of descriptions of how perfect, beautiful and admirable Edith is which can get on one's nerves...but I liked it apart from that.)
Hospital Sketches (1863)- A really sweet compilation of diary entries (however, not in typical diary format) of when Louisa Alcott was a Civil War Nurse. In the story, her name is put as "Nurse Periwinkle." I'd readily reccommend this one to anyone. Usually, Hospital Sketches is accompanied by Camp and Fireside Stories which is about five or so short stories, some based on the Civil War. (Since there are some Confederates around NW, I'll quickly warn that Louisa May Alcott was for the Union and a strong abolitionist and it definitely shows up in these two books specifically.) I really don't know if I'd reccomend Camp and Fireside Stories as it wasn't amazing, due to some negative elements (nothing too serious, just on the tip of being...well, gory in a sense but not quite.)
Little Women or Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy (1868) I think we all know what this one's about. ;))
Part Second of Little Women, also known as "Good Wives" (1869) Ditto^
An Old Fashioned Girl (1870) Plot: Young, innocent Polly comes to vacation with her very air-minded cousin, Fanny in the city. Polly is very ashamed at girls' behaviour in the city, and doesn't wish to change her sweet country ways. It's a really great book, and as someone here noted, relates quite well to youth of today.
Little Men: Life at Plumfield with Jo's Boys (1871) Sequel to Little Men, my most favourite of the series.
Eight Cousins or The Aunt-Hill (1875) Ahhh, I love this one! Rose comes to the Aunt-Hill to stay with her two aunts, and she has a couple relatives around. She's very quiet and shy and is startled when introduced to seven boys who are to be her playmates. (all the boys are sweet, and grow to be very lovable by the end of the book) However, she's relieved a little by Phebe, the maid who becomes her bosom friend. Such a great book!
Rose in Bloom: A Sequel to Eight Cousins (1876) We figure out what happens to all the characters in this one- typical Louisa May Alcott in covering every character's life. There is some melancholy in losing a character, but everyone ends up with the majority-preferred person. ;))
Under the Lilacs (1878) I can't believe it, but a lot of people don't like this one. Granted, the first two chapters are rather hard to get into but once you keep reading, it's such a charming story! About a young boy, Ben, and his dog Sancho. He befriends two girls and their mother, along with a young lady and her younger brother who's around Ben's age.
Jack and Jill: A Village Story (1880) About a girl and boy, Jack and Jill (her name is something else, though. I forget what.) who get into a sledding accident and throughout the whole book, have an interesting recovery. Their ending is pretty obvious. :P
Jo's Boys and How They Turned Out: A Sequel to "Little Men" (1886) And Jo's Boys is the conclusion of the Little Women triology. A wonderful book, but Little Men is more light-hearted and usually a favourite.

I think that's majority of her novels and there are short-story books such as A Garland for Girls, Lulu's Library, etc. The other two short story books by her are The Brownie and the Princess and Other Stories which has other darling short stories, and Glimpses of Louisa which is different short stories from Aunt Jo's Scrap Bag and A Garland for Girls. I haven't finished this one yet, but I'm enjoying it muchly!

Feel free to discuss movie adaptations on Louisia May Alcott books, and the like!
(And pardon any repetetiveness or grammatical errors, please. I wrote this in a hurry and I'm tired. ;)) )


RL Sibling: CSLewisNarnia

Topic starter Posted : March 31, 2010 5:22 pm
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

I really love Louisa's writing style- I need to read more of her books :) . As of now I've only read parts of Little Women and An Old-Fashioned Girl. I absolutely adored An Old-Fashioned Girl and I think some of her other books sound very interesting- I've been meaning to read more for a while ;)) :) .

Posted : March 31, 2010 5:55 pm
narnian1
(@narnian1)
NarniaWeb Guru

I've only read one of her books to date but I have planned several more.
Little Women, I read it for the first time Dec '08 and I absolutely loved it!
There were several chapters I could have done without, but when compared to the rest of the book it is not such a big deal.

From the moment I started I was hooked,
and I nearly cried when... if you all read the book you know what I am referring to. It broke me.

Posted : March 31, 2010 7:00 pm
Aslanisthebest
(@aslanisthebest)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

ditto, gtg, about an old fashioned girl. it was a really fun book and the end was touching. pretty predicatble, but because of a few twists peopel get relieved at the ending. ;)) do finish it! :) u'll really enjoy it, i think.

that's true, narnian1! little women is really, really hard to put down but then when one reaches that part... i bawled. what's worse is that i cried even harder when

Spoiler
laurie and amy ended up toghether...
because of that bit, little women is probably one of my least favourites but apart from that, the book is one of louisa may alcott's books. :)


RL Sibling: CSLewisNarnia

Topic starter Posted : April 1, 2010 11:15 am
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

^oh I meant I've only read parts of Little Women. I have read all of An Old Fashioned Girl though :p :) .

Posted : April 1, 2010 11:20 am
narnian1
(@narnian1)
NarniaWeb Guru

what's worse is that i cried even harder when

Spoiler
laurie and amy ended up toghether...

you know,
, hoping it wouldn't go through, but when it did- I loved it :D

GTG,
you should definitely read all of Little Women

Posted : April 1, 2010 3:03 pm
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

^hehe, maybe soon. I read like 2/3 of it but found it too boring. But that was like 5 years ago soo....

Posted : April 1, 2010 3:05 pm
narnian1
(@narnian1)
NarniaWeb Guru

^hehe, maybe soon. I read like 2/3 of it but found it too boring. But that was like 5 years ago soo....

well, maybe you should try the movie. There's 3, my favorite is the 1995 version, even though the second half isn't 100% faithful to the book. I have a friend you disliked the book, too boring for her, but she did love the movie. It happens sometimes.

Posted : April 1, 2010 3:27 pm
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

I saw one version...can't remember which it was though..oh now I remember, it was the one with Elizabeth Taylor as...Amy I think.

Posted : April 1, 2010 4:18 pm
Heroine of Chivalry
(@heroine-of-chivalry)
NarniaWeb Nut

*runs in very quickly*

I've read:
Little Women (including the second half) -- I love it. I can see myself in each of the girls, I love the character growth, it is very well written and altogether delightful.

Little Men I love all the different children and incidents. And it is really nice to see all the March girls as adults.

An Old Fashioned Girl I really love the first half, the second one not so much.

Eight Cousins Very good, especially because there is no romance.

An excerpt from Hospital Sketches Made me cry it did.

I've also read several of her short stories, but I don't recall their titles at the moment.

As far as movie adaptions go, of Little Women I've seen 193- one, 1978, and 1995. None of them are anything that you should judge the book by as they all made major changes. The 1978 is my personal favorite because they left in the most from the book, I really like Jo, Mr. Bhaer is actually close to his book character (unlike the terrible Mr. Bhaer in the 1995), and it only has a couple of kisses or anything inappropriate. However, it does have several other problems (the

Spoiler
Meg/John engagement scene
was somewhat disturbing and completely out of character) so don't think I approve of all of it. :)

Thanks for starting this, Bella!

*runs back out*

I left Narniaweb for inexplicable reasons in the beginning of June 2010 and probably will not be returning (much as I love this place). So if you're wondering why I disappeared, now you know! (sort of...)

Posted : April 1, 2010 4:30 pm
narnian1
(@narnian1)
NarniaWeb Guru

I saw one version...can't remember which it was though..oh now I remember, it was the one with Elizabeth Taylor as...Amy I think.

I believe Amy is the youngest daughter in that movie. I hated that one! I disliked the earlier version too. my problem:

The earliest version, had some faithful parts to it, but it had much wrong too.
Second version was a remake of the first, and not so much an adaptation of the book. So what happened? They kept much of what was wrong in the first, and messed up even further parts including Amy's age. The 95 version is the most faithful IMO, although I know people that prefer the second or the earlier one still.

Posted : April 1, 2010 4:33 pm
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

^I'll have to judge for myself after I've read the whole book :p

Posted : April 1, 2010 4:35 pm
Heroine of Chivalry
(@heroine-of-chivalry)
NarniaWeb Nut

Good idea, GtG.

I forgot to say that I do think that the 1995 version has the best Jo, I like a lot of things about Marmee, Meg, and young Amy in that one as well. The only reason I don't like Meg completely the best is because of the scene between Jo and Meg in the 1978 after

Spoiler
Jo cuts her hair.

Also, one of the main reasons I prefer the 1978 is because Beth is almost perfect in that one, while the others (only in my opinion of course) completely missed her character. I also really liked the adaption changes they made (combining events instead of leaving them out altogether, not showing
Spoiler
Beth's death
, etc.

I've decided that Laurie's character is impossible to capture on screen, does anyone agree with me?

*suddenly realizes that she is now really late for a very important date and scuttles out*

I left Narniaweb for inexplicable reasons in the beginning of June 2010 and probably will not be returning (much as I love this place). So if you're wondering why I disappeared, now you know! (sort of...)

Posted : April 1, 2010 4:41 pm
daughter of the King
(@dot)
Princess Dot Moderator

Let's see, I have read Little Women, Little Men, Jo's Boys, An Old Fashioned Girl, Jack and Jill, Under the Lilacs, Eight Cousins, and Rose in Bloom. Out of all of those, I think Jack and Jill was my favorite. I really liked Jack. I preferred Rose in Bloom over Eight Cousins, not sure why.

As for movies, I have seen The Inheritance, Little Men, and four versions of Little Women. It has been a very long time since I saw Inheritance, but I remember liking it a lot. Little Men I saw so long ago it isn't really even worth mentioning since I don't remember anything. Hands down my favorite version of Little Women is the '70s. It was spectacular! The advantage of a miniseries over a movie is more can go into a miniseries. And this particular miniseries had superb casting. Greer Garson is amazing as Aunt March, Dorothy MacGuire simply is Marmee, and I forget who played Beth but I liked her.

The 1978 is my personal favorite because they left in the most from the book, I really like Jo, Mr. Bhaer is actually close to his book character (unlike the terrible Mr. Bhaer in the 1995),

ditto that. William Shatner is the only really good Professor Bhaer I have seen.

I saw one version...can't remember which it was though..oh now I remember, it was the one with Elizabeth Taylor as...Amy I think.

That's the '40s one. Yes, Elizabeth Taylor played Amy. I liked that one.

ahsokasig
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal

Posted : April 1, 2010 5:30 pm
Meltintalle
(@mel)
Member Moderator

Let's see... I've read: Little Women, Little Men, Jo's Boys, An Old Fashioned Girl, Under the Lilacs, Eight Cousins, Rose in Bloom, The Brownie and the Princess and Other Stories, The Quiet Little Woman, and Kate's Choice.

(I will also admit to reading and enjoying the Portraits of Little Women series by Susan Beth Pfeffer. :p Anyone else remember those? I want to say that there was another series with the same theme around the same time. They had the cutest illustrations--or so I recall. They might have been done by the same people who did the Treasured Horses series.)

I believe my favourite Louisa May Alcott book is Old Fashioned Girl. Either that or Little Men which is the very first book by her I ever read. Awwwwww. Also, I like Jo's Boys better than Little Women.

We have hands that fashion and heads that know,
But our hearts we lost - how long ago! -- G. K. Chesterton

Posted : April 2, 2010 8:47 am
Page 1 / 2
Share: