Forum

Share:
Notifications
Clear all

[Closed] SF: All Things L.M. Montgomery

Aslanisthebest
(@aslanisthebest)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

Lucy Maud Montgomery, or "Maud" for short, was a Canadian author from the Victorian era that imagined up one of the most influential, dear girl characters: Anne of Green Gables. (the first book was published in 1908)

Her novels: (list courtesy of Wikipedia.com)

Anne of Green Gables (1908)
Anne of Avonlea (1909) (sequel to Anne of Green Gables)
Kilmeny of the Orchard (1910)
The Story Girl (1911)
The Golden Road (1913) (sequel to The Story Girl)
Anne of the Island (1915) (sequel to Anne of Avonlea)
Anne's House of Dreams (1917) (sequel to Anne of Windy Poplars)
Rainbow Valley (1919) (sequel to Anne of Ingleside)
Rilla of Ingleside (1921) (sequel to Rainbow Valley)
Emily of New Moon (1923)
Emily Climbs (1925) (sequel to Emily of New Moon)
The Blue Castle (1926)
Emily's Quest (1927) (sequel to Emily Climbs)
Magic for Marigold (1929)
A Tangled Web (1931)
Pat of Silver Bush (1933)
Mistress Pat (1935) (sequel to Pat of Silver Bush)
Anne of Windy Poplars (1936) (sequel to Anne of the Island)
Jane of Lantern Hill (1937)
Anne of Ingleside (1939) (sequel to Anne's House of Dreams)
The Blythes Are Quoted, edited by Benjamin Lefebvre (2009) (sequel to Rilla of Ingleside)

This is the place to discuss all of L.M. Montgomery's books, the movies (whether the animated miniseries or movies from Sullivan Entertainment, or Akage no An [the anime version of Anne of Green Gables] by Neppon Studios (who have done quite a few classics, too.), and all that jazz in general. :)

Enjoy!

Questions (and feel free to add any to this list: I just did them to start a conversation)
1. Which of L.M. Montgomery's books have you read?
2. Which is your favourite?
3. What is your favourite thing about Montgomery's writing?
4. Have you seen any of the movies/series based on her work? If so, what did you think?

1. I have read all the Anne books (except for The Blythes are Quoted. Christmas With Anne and Other Stories is at the library waiting for me - squee!), all the Emily books (I actually fully read the first two, and kind of briefly read, skipping this and that, to read the basics of what happened to everybody.), and Magic for Marigold. That's all I can remember. I /need/ to read more.
2. Undoubtedly, the Anne series: and in the Anne series, I really enjoyed Anne of Green Gables, Anne of Windy Poplars, and Rainbow Valley. Least favourite definitely Rilla of Ingleside. I liked the general LMM feeling, the Anne feeling, and the sadness, and I could relate to Rilla on one or two things, but overall... I had a hard time liking Rilla, so it was hard to read the book. :P
3. Definitely how beautifully she describes the weather, the scenery, the people, and everyday things of life. It's so deep, true, relatable, and sounds "just like a line of music." Even if I didn't enjoy the general plot in some books, like a few of the Anne books, the writing style of Montgomery was just beautiful to read.
4. I used to watch the animated Sullivan episodes on PBS kids, which was a very interesting part of my young childhood. And I watched the first Anne of Green Gables movie (by Sullivan, the one with Megan Follows) and I /loved/ it, for the most part. That DVD is definitely one of my treasures. :D

Well, my wrist about gave out, so I'll hit submit... *turns Anne of Green Gable soundtrack music on get the conversation going* :D


RL Sibling: CSLewisNarnia

Topic starter Posted : November 11, 2011 10:46 am
Meltintalle
(@mel)
Member Moderator

Huh. According to that list, I've read everything but The Blythes are Quoted, and possibly The Golden Road which I can't quite remember if I've read or not. :p

It's rather interesting to see the publication order, so that you can see how her writing matured over the years!

My favourite book is a three-way tie between Anne of the Island, Anne of Windy Poplars and The Blue Castle. (Funny story--the first time I started Anne of the Island I couldn't finish it; for whatever reason it was too much of something and not enough of another.)

Has anyone been to Prince Edward Island to see any of the sites dedicated to Montgomery and her work? If so, what did you like? What would you recommend as a 'must see?' :)

We have hands that fashion and heads that know,
But our hearts we lost - how long ago! -- G. K. Chesterton

Posted : November 12, 2011 3:56 am
daughter of the King
(@dot)
Princess Dot Moderator

1. Which of L.M. Montgomery's books have you read? The easier question would be which ones haven't I read. ;)) Off of that list the only one I haven't read is The Blythes are Quoted. I remember seeing short story collections at the library which I think were really collections of unfinished works published posthumously but don't quote me on that. :p

2. Which is your favourite? The Blue Castle Followed very closely by Rilla of Ingleside. I recently re-read Blue Castle. I had forgotten how much I adore that book. I also really like Anne of the Island and Jane of Lantern Hill.

3. What is your favourite thing about Montgomery's writing? The characters. Even her minor characters tend to be very memorable. In some books, such as A Tangled Web, the characters are very stereotypical, but even so they're so much fun to read about and I always want to know what will happen to them.

4. Have you seen any of the movies/series based on her work? If so, what did you think? I have seen the Sullivan movie version of Anne as well as the sequel. I haven't seen the third one though. There was a live-action miniseries of Anne of Green Gables and Anne of Avonlea that I saw but I don't remember who made it.

ahsokasig
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal

Posted : November 12, 2011 4:07 am
wisewoman
(@wisewoman)
Member Moderator Emeritus

I love Montgomery's work! I reread the Anne series about a year ago and going in, I wasn't sure if the books were going to hold up to the wonderful memories I had of them. Well, they surpassed my recollections!

Least favourite definitely Rilla of Ingleside. I liked the general LMM feeling, the Anne feeling, and the sadness, and I could relate to Rilla on one or two things, but overall... I had a hard time liking Rilla, so it was hard to read the book. :P

How funny! That and Anne of Green Gables tie for my favorites of the series. I know it has a very different feel, but I liked the way Montgomery intertwined the events of the larger world during WWI with the small-town feel of life in Avonlea. Rilla isn't my favorite heroine but I still like her very much.

The Blue Castle is another favorite. I've read it a couple times and it is high on my comfort reads list. So satisfying!

I have been thinking about rereading the Emily books; it's been awhile. This SF might just push me to pick them up :)

"It is God who gives happiness; for he is the true wealth of men's souls." — Augustine

Posted : November 12, 2011 11:21 am
Princess Anna
(@princess-anna)
NarniaWeb Junkie

Interesting, I don't know if I ever heard that she went by her middle name. Shows what I know! :)) Guess my "expertise" lies elsewhere. (Laura Ingalls Wilder and Lousia May Alcott, to be more precise)

1. Which of L.M. Montgomery's books have you read?
Just the "Anne books". ;))

Though I'm not sure if I ever read Rilla of Ingleside or not. I can't remember, and it's bugging me.

2. Which is your favourite?
Hmm... it's been forever since I read them, but I think I'd have to go with Rainbow Valley. I think. I'd have to reread them all to be sure. I remember thinking that the kids at the Manse were hilarious. And I adored Walter.

3. What is your favourite thing about Montgomery's writing?
The characters. I'm definitely the type of reader/writer/viewer who is very into character-driven things. I mean, plots matter too, of course. But it's characters that draw me into a world more than anything. And Montgomery's are so... so... memorable and funny and sweet!

4. Have you seen any of the movies/series based on her work? If so, what did you think?
I think we've had this conversation before, but I'll answer anyway. ;))

I've seen the movies that had Megan Follows as Anne. I'm also very picky about them too, for some reason. (like I am with a lot of book-to-film adaptations, though not all)

Movie #1-
Was based off of Anne of Green Gables. And I thought it was very accurate, and very lovely. I adored this movie, and thought Megan was the perfect choice to play Anne. If it was possible, she made me love the character more than I ever had!

Movie #2-
If I remember right, it seemed to me, to be based off of books 2-4 (?). And was fairly accurate, though it's hard to be super accurate when smashing that many books together. Very well done, though. Still loved it.

Movie #3-
This is where it gets tricky for me. On the one hand, it's NOT BASED OFF CANON AT ALL. If you ignore the fact that it's supposedly about Anne and Gilbert, it's lovely... fascinating... and a great time period piece.

But make it about our beloved characters... sorry. I just can't get past that for some reason. It was too weird. I missed Jem, the twins, Walter, and the rest. I really wish that if they wanted to continue making films, that they would have stuck with the stories in the books. If you all like it, that's fine... I'm glad you enjoyed it! I'm just sorry that I couldn't.

...........
Who are everyone else's favourite characters?
Are there any other movie/tv adaptations that I should look into?

It's weird, I've known of those (about Anne and her kids) for ages, and I knew she wrote stuff other than them. But I never really read them. Should I add them to my ever-growing list of things to read in my lifetime? And if so, which ones should be at the top?

Posted : November 12, 2011 11:35 am
Eraisuithiel
(@eraisuithiel)
NarniaWeb Newbie

ive only read anne of green gables and bits and pieces of others..i live in canada though but on the west:)
i would like to watch the movie sometime...Anne ended up with KIDS???!!
im definitely reading them now.

"..certainty of death, small chance of success-what are we waiting for?!?"-Gimli Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

Posted : November 15, 2011 11:40 am
johobbit
(@jo)
SO mod; WC captain Moderator

Please note that this Special Feature will be closing on Monday, January 9, after which you may discuss L.M. Montgomery's writings and the adaptations in the relevant Books or Movies topics. :)


Signature by Narnian_Badger, thanks! (2013)
7,237 posts from Forum 1.0

Posted : January 3, 2012 7:46 am
MountainFireflower
(@mountainfireflower)
Member Moderator Emeritus

1. Which of L.M. Montgomery's books have you read?

I think, sadly, that I have only read Anne of Green Gables, and some of Anne of Avonlea.

2. Which is your favourite?

See above. ;))

3. What is your favourite thing about Montgomery's writing?

Well... honestly... I love Anne of Green Gables in general. I love Montgomery's ability to draw us perfectly into the story. I love how I feel like I know all of them... Anne, Marilla, Diana. L.M. Montgomery does a fantastic job of getting us attached to these characters and their world, and I love that.

4. Have you seen any of the movies/series based on her work? If so, what did you think?

I loved the Anne of Green Gables movie with Megan Follows. It was one of my favorite movies as a kid (and still is). As for the sequels, I don't love them as much. Anne of Avonlea was a decent movie, although I don't think it was close to the original book, but I still liked it. And whatever that third one was called, where

Spoiler
Gilbert goes off to the war
, yuck... didn't like that one much. ;))

What are your thoughts on the movie adaptations?

av by dot

Posted : January 7, 2012 7:14 am
Share: