Forum

Share:
Notifications
Clear all

[Closed] HUGE plothole in books!

Page 1 / 3
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

My sister, my friend, and I were listening to the FotF audio dramas and my sister pointed out that in VODT, Reepicheep says the song was sung over him by a dryad but if it was, he must be really old because the dryads were asleep in PC! The timeline doesn't add up! How could a dryad sing a song over him if it was "dead"?

Topic starter Posted : November 12, 2009 4:53 pm
daughter of the King
(@dot)
Princess Dot Moderator

I've noticed that before. The answer is: I don't know. We can only hope that it's one of the things C.S.Lewis was going to correct in the revisions that he was planning.

ahsokasig
Narniaweb sister to Pattertwig's Pal

Posted : November 12, 2009 5:05 pm
narnia365
(@narnia365)
NarniaWeb Regular

Woah, I never thought of that! Wow...

"We have to travel to another dimension to rescue his father."
"That is so Narnia! Can I come?"
-Beyond the Reflections Edge, by Bryan Davis

Posted : November 13, 2009 3:07 am
Valiant_Lucy
(@valiant_lucy)
Member Moderator Emeritus

Wow, very good point. Perhaps the dryad sort of came un-asleep, or maybe it sung to him in a dream or something.

"Imperfection is beauty, madness is genius, and it's better to be absolutely ridiculous than absolutely boring." Marilyn Monroe

Posted : November 13, 2009 7:04 am
Watziznehm
(@watziznehm)
NarniaWeb Junkie

That is a very good point. Maybe their was a time when the dryads were un-asleep in the most remotest parts of Narnia and were asleep in the inhabited parts. Reepicheep was born in that time period. Maybe afterward the Telmarines started pressing further into the unknown regions and silenced the dryads all together.


Sig by greenleaf23.

Posted : November 13, 2009 8:01 am
Glenstorm the Great
(@glenstorm-the-great)
NarniaWeb Fanatic

Yeah those are all possibilities. It's just kinda wierd the Lewis would leave a gap like that. :|

Topic starter Posted : November 13, 2009 3:19 pm
Lion's Emblem
(@lions-emblem)
NarniaWeb Guru

I never thought of this case as a gap in the storyline. I just always assumed that the dryad came to Reepicheep in a dream. In PC, when Lucy sees the dryads in the night, she recalls it as being very dreamlike. Suppose this is more of the same. Aslan works in mysterious ways. He knew Reepicheep needed to know this information, as part of his life's destiny, so he sent one of his servants, a dryad, to relay the message.


Sig by Dernhelm_of_Rohan
NWsis to eves_daughter & ForeverFan

Posted : November 13, 2009 6:18 pm
ChristProclamer
(@christproclamer)
NarniaWeb Nut

I never thought about that at all... :-o
I'd like to think that if Reepicheep said it was a dryad, it was a dryad. If it had been a dream he probably would have mentioned it becuase magical/prophetical dreams are quite glorious, I think.
So...maybe it was, er, a very resilient dryad, one of the last to retreat within herself...or maybe Aslan just woke her up.

Posted : November 13, 2009 8:12 pm
Jill_of_Narnia
(@jill_of_narnia)
NarniaWeb Regular

Ah yes, I posted a thread about that a long time ago. I just thought either Lewis forgot, therefore, a plot hole. Or, that Aslan let that Dryad be awake so that she could sing that song to him and it would tie in with his future.

"The term is over: the holidays have begun. The dream is ended:this is the morning."
And as He spoke, He no longer looked to them like a lion.

Posted : November 14, 2009 1:37 pm
decarus
(@decarus)
NarniaWeb Junkie

I think that Aslan bringing the dryad awake for this one moment makes the most sense and is highly plausible. Lewis may have forgotten, but that covers the problem for me, if it is a problem.

There are no clouds in the sky. There is only the open sun and the Lord watches.

Posted : November 14, 2009 2:55 pm
Pattertwigs Pal
(@twigs)
Member Moderator

I have often wondered about this. I figured maybe she (dryads are females right?) was a little rebellious and didn't go to sleep. Maybe Aslan appeared to the dryad in a dream (since they are sleeping it would make since they were dreaming too) so she woke up to bring Reep his prophecy. The trees seem to be able to still do somethings in their sleep. It is implied that they caused problems for Caspian in his escape.


NW sister to Movie Aristotle & daughter of the King

Posted : November 17, 2009 5:43 am
Hermitess of Narnia
(@hermitess-of-narnia)
NarniaWeb Regular

I had thought of this before too.
Maybe not all of the dryads were asleep until Miraz took over. Dr. Cornelius says that Caspian IX was a good king, so maybe there were still some around. Aside from this, I do wonder how long talking mice live.


Narnia Comics: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=5560

Posted : November 17, 2009 11:53 am
Liberty Hoffman
(@liberty-hoffman)
NarniaWeb Master

hullo, ya'll! I am the 'friend' Glenstorm The Great mentioned in the first post of this topic!
ya'll have some great theorys as to what this glitch in VotDT might mean! it is so strange that Lewis would make a big thing about the nyads and dryads being asleep, and then make an exeption. but oh well! it still weirds me out to think about now that i've noticed it, but every author makes a mistake from time to time. so I won't worry about it! :D


NW sister - wild rose ~ NW big sis - ramagut
Born in the water
Take quick to the trees
I want all that You are

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EADBC57vKfQ

Posted : November 18, 2009 9:07 am
Benjamin
(@benjamin)
NarniaWeb Guru

This is a interesting topic I never noticed that before very interesting.....


Avvie By Flambeau Sig by Ithilwen
Team Hoodie!!

Posted : November 19, 2009 9:34 am
Aravis Narnia
(@aravis-narnia)
NarniaWeb Nut

Maybe a dryad managed to survive and come out of the spell and sing to him.

It is a possibility after all.

Posted : November 20, 2009 12:08 pm
Page 1 / 3
Share: