I LOVE this picture, Silver! you did an amazing job with it!

*Squeee*

I love this. I love everything about this. I love the fact that he looks youngish, his hair and his outfit are cool, and for some reason I really like the way you drew his nose. The only con I see is that his face might not be long enough to match up to Lewis's description, but all in all, this is an awesome drawing. You're amazing.

Hey Sliver,

I really like the detail you put into this drawing. But then again, I always love all your work.

Great job,

Windsong

Amazing job Silver! I Love it!
The details are awesome, and really Love the detail in his hands!
I also love the scene you chose, that’s the first scene I think of when I think of Puddleglum! Great Job!

wow awesome great job, I really like it, I love the greyness, it really does bring out Puddleglums character

I agree, it does look like a young Puddleglum. I like the twinkle in his eye. Much to happy for a proper marshwiggle and I shouldn't wonder if he catches a giant eel and falls in and drowns. Or it'll rain just when he tries to light a fire to cook his dinner...

I like what you did with the colouring. It looks particularly good on Puddleglum. The folds in his clothes are very realistic and give his clothes a feeling of substance. I do think you might have wanted to use a smaller brush for the reeds in the background; they're quite thick and stick-like.

All around, an excellent drawing.

I love it! The grayscale definitely adds to the gloomy feeling of the characters, very nice! And I think the background is just perfect - matches the style in which the character is drawn and just the right amount of detail - enough to make it a particular background, but it doesn't take attention away from Puddleglum He looks perhaps too pleasant, but it's hard to draw a character as perfecly gloomy and brooding as him I really adore it and yay, welcome to the campaign!

Thank you, Elle! I'm glad you like it!

You too, Rose! Thank you! *bows* Haha, you're right about his face, though. It was long(er) before I put his hat on...or then again, maybe it wasn't!

Thank you so much, Windsong!

7, I'm glad you like the scene I chose! That's the first one that comes to mind for me as well, when I think of Puddleglum. Thank you!

Thanks, wild rose! I'm glad you like the greys - I thought they were very Puddleglummy.

Thank you very much, Mel! Now that I think about it, this easily could be a young Puddleglum from before SC! Thanks for the tip about the brush - I was sort of in a hurry to finish up the background. But it'd be easy to go back and redo the reeds if I ever felt like it.

Thanks, Beginte! Yes, emotions are a bit tricky for me yet, something I have to work on. But I'm glad you like the colors and the background! Thank you for letting me join the campaign!

Oh, I think the emotions worked out great, I'm just saying it's hard to draw a face as perfectly gloomy and huffed as Puddleglum's! The background is simply 100% perfect, so well balanced in amount of detail! Oh, it is I who thank you for joining the campaign, I didn't think anyone would

Ah, I see. In that case, yes, I agree. What I meant was that expressions are one of the things I'd like to improve on in general. I had look at so many different reference pictures to get this one to turn out.
Your campaign is a neat idea! Now I just have to think of what to draw next...

Yes, expressions can be tricky sometimes... for me it's odd, in some cases I need reference, and in others, even the most intense expressions, they sort of come out on their own, without any examples for me

Oh, I know, I'm wondering what to draw next, too... apart from coloring my two sketches, the Black Knight and the symbolic drawing. Rilian I will leave as a sketch. Oh, I know - Rilian on Silver Chair (duh ), I just remembered an elderly sketch I made in Photoshop, I'll get to work on it soon!

By the way, the sharpening tutorial for you is ready I hope I managed to be at least somewhat coherent, if there are any doubts just let me know!

Oh wow! this is amazing! I really love the shading, it is so real looking, and I really love your interpretation of Puddleglum. He is a really amazing effort, and the background is perfect, I don't know what you were worrying about