I liked all three of them.

I voted yes for all 3.

Yes for LWW
Yes for PC
No for VDT

Despite the weaknesses of PC and VDT, I like all three Then again, I have no other movie versions to compare with. My votes may be different if they redo the movies some 30 years later

Yes for all 3

I voted yes, yes, and yes. I did like them all, although like aslanscountry I had nothing to compare them to.

Are you doing this for a specific project or just because? Just curious.

Are you doing this for a specific project or just because? Just curious.

It's not for any specific project, I just wanted to get a general idea of the percentage of fans that were satisfied with each film. I know that almost everybody liked LWW, but that a lot of people didn't like PC and VDT...I am interested to see how those numbers compare to the people you did.

I hope people won't be shy to vote no just because most people are voting yes...this poll is anonymous, I just want to know what the overall honest feeling was.

LWW - yes
PC - yes
VDT - no

I voted yes for LWW. I adored that movie. I thought, for the most part, it captured the Narnia I knew from the books.

I voted yes for PC, though I was kind of on the fence about it. There were many, many parts I hated about it. Especially the changes they made to my favorite character, Trumpkin. But the beautiful way they portrayed Aslan and Lucy's relationship kind of made up for it.

I voted no for VDT. I abhorred it. I thought it was boring, unemotional, humanistic, and low quality.

~Riella

Voted yes for all three because I loved them all!

Yes, to all three of them. Though PC could have been shorter and not had Susaspian. Otherwise, no other criticisms from me.

Yeah to LWW, PC, and VDT, because they all had their flaws, but overall I am very excited that they were made!

I liked LWW and PC very much, but I was really disappointed with VDT. To me, it had the potential to be the best one, but because the filmmakers didn't take the risk of showing the book as it was, but changed it completely and left it hollow, it is the worst one yet, and even a mediocre film on its own.

Ah, this is kind of hard for me where PC is concerned because I'm really on the fence about it. There were things I liked, but also many things I hated about it, and I can't decide which one outweighs the other. So I think I won't vote on that one.

But it's a definite yes for LWW and VDT, regardless of the changes that I disliked in VDT.