i believe that LWW has the more "scary" parts. due to all the creatures in the witches army and the stone table scene.

I would have to say LWW. More creatures which looked so real and the scene when they sacrificed Aslan by Jadis, that was all too real and very scary!

Cant think of any scary parts in PC, just a lot of action, mostly the battle scenes and when Peter was fighting Miraz.

Well...I think PC is more violent and scary overall, but LWW has fewer, but scarier scenes, mainly Aslan's sacrifice.

Hm, well this is tough for me because I wouldn't say either is "scary" but in terms of violence I would say PC. PC is also much darker but very good.

Hm, well this is tough for me because I wouldn't say either is "scary" but in terms of violence I would say PC.

Yep. What he said, lol. The witch was a perfect villain in LWW and the sacrifice scene was pretty dark, but I think PC takes the cake here.

I believe LWW has the darkest moments. As my posts in my TAN thread surely indicate , I find a cold, ancient Witch with the use of magic on her side a little bit scarier than Miraz. Although the films made him quite scary too.

At one point the first time I saw PC, I was actually bored with it...and I was not bored with LWW. Still, since that was before the night raid that I was feeling that way, I think PC had more drama and violent action. If I recall correctly, the ratings on the DVD covers say, "Rated PG for frightening moments" (LWW) and "Rated PG for epic battle action" (PC).

I thought about my own question for a while, and I have to say that I think that PC is scarier.....mostly because of parts like the night raid and when the hag calls up the White Witch.....

If I recall correctly, the ratings on the DVD covers say, "Rated PG for frightening moments" (LWW) and "Rated PG for epic battle action" (PC).

Your pretty much right I've got them right here: LWW-"PG: For Battle Sequences And Frightening Moments" , PC- "PG: For Epic Battle Action And Violence"

Well, when I first saw LWW I was only nine, so I thought some parts, namely Aslan's sacrifice and any part with the White Witch, were really scary. But after I saw PC, I think that while LWW's scary moments are made darker by the fact that they're more spaced out, that PC is overall scarier. Mostly because of all the violence.

Pyxis: and in PC, the action is almost non-stop! so the scary parts are all one after the other and there is almost no break in between!

This is an interesting subject. Like people have said before, the creatures are much scarier in LWW. Especially in the extended version which my family owns. They show more of the White Witchs animals and creatures. tHe whole scene where they sacrifice Aslan can be considered scary.

PC isn't scary. It's action packed. The only scary thing is really the hag which my Mom doesn't like. I think that LWW is scarier, and PC is just filled with action.

The White Witches minions in Aslan's sacrifice seen are creepy-looking (LWW) as is the hag in the dark magic scene (PC). Really, that scene is the only part that creeps me out. Messing around with spirits is dangerous.

I have always found the scene in PC where Caspian has the sword on Miraz's throat to be the most scary or tense in either movie. No matter how many times I see it, I'm always on edge until it's over.

Other than that, I haven't really found much of the movies all that scary...

Perhaps not the most scary scenes, but I think LWW was a scarier film.

I might just be thinking that because PC was a "darker film" than its predecessor, so you didn't really notice the scary parts. In LWW, it felt like a more 'oh this is nice' kind of a film when you were watching it, so the scary bits - like the sacrifice, or the ice castle, or the wolfie attacks and such were sort of 'Wow - what's happening! Arrrhhh'. Or maybe that's just me!

Plus, I think the subject matter was more unnerving in LWW - child abduction, sacrifice. Although, one might argue that attempted murder is pretty worrying too!