Hmmm... Well, we're correct, now I need to remember the Chronicles to get the answer even further!

Thanks Hugh.

"Precious water" reminds me of Goldwater in Voyage of the Dawn Treader.

Just for curiosity's sake... I noticed that the Peacock Alliance is ruling out mods who were previously falsely accused. But just because a mod was innocent in a previous round, does that mean they still are? Or is the "Dragonish" infection spreading?

Well, it seems you've figure it out! You were right, it is water from Deathwater/Goldwater Island. Now, the book the magician kindly donated to me says the following:

To break the dragonish enchantment, the following pictures must be posted, in the order given, one picture per post. There may be no double posting. The pictures are as follows:
1. Gold statue
2. Heather
3. Sword
4. Shell
5. Mail coat
6. Detective book
7. Lucy
8. Reepicheep
9. Eustace
10. Boots
11. Edmund and Caspian fighting
12. A ship
13. Coins
14. A beach
15. Aslan

Well, that's quite the job. Good luck with that, and once you've finished, feel free to jump back into the main game! Just make sure you post all fifteen pictures!

Wait, so we post the pictures here?

Yikes. That's quite the shopping list. I will have to let my teammates take care of that, as I have been sadly neglecting other duties to embark on this murder mystery.

Good luck all. If you're still not done by the time I have some free time, I'll try to help out!