I don't think I would care if the LOTGK was American or British. Personally, I think though that a witch should have a very bewitching voice. So, they have to go with some one who can pull of a witch look,(but still look pretty) and who has that warm voice that is bewitching.

Something like when Imelda Staunton played Dolores Umbridge. She played that character so darn well! Really made you want to hate the character. But of course the last thing we want is for her to play the LotGK.

Um, yeah...Imelda Staunton would just be wierd.

I still vote Emily Blunt. She's so perfect for the part, I'm really getting to where I can't see anyone else. That could be a bad thing...

I don't know, Emily Blunt just doesn't seem as enchanting as the LOTGK is in my head. I always pictured her with a more heart shaped or oval face, rather than Emily who has more of a square jaw. Don't get me wrong, I think Emily is beautiful, I just imagine the LOTGK beautiful in a more delicate way.

What about Amanda Seyfried? Though she might look a bit too young now that I look at her.

Or what about Rachelle Lefevre?

I would like Keira Knightly for the part if she dyed her hair and eyebrows red. That way she would seperate herself from previous roles.

I think Keira can look "innocently pretty" when she wants to and "seducitively pretty" when she wants to. And that would allow the filmakers to play it both ways.

Yea, I think Keira Knightly would be a good choice too, my only problem with her is that she might be a little to young.
I always pictured the LOTGK as someone at least in her 30's, I just can't picture her as a young women.

What about Milla Jovovich? I've not seen her act before, but she certainly looks the part. They would just have to make her hair longer, but thats not too big a problem.

Mila is too famous for her Resident Evil movies. I cant see her going for a role or accepting a role for Narnia.

WHo cares if an actor is famous? Is Narnia forbidden from having any famous actors?

For the most part I think actors, especially the kids, should be fairly unknown. But I think roles like Puddleglum, the Lady of the Green Kirtle, and Uncle Andrew should be cast by well known actors.

Do you think Brooke Shields would be a good choice? She is very pretty, plus a good actress, and she recently showed she can play a villain on a TV Halloween movie.

~Riella

Who cares if an actor is famous? Is Narnia forbidden from having any famous actors?

Narnia already has several famous actors, Liam Neeson is Very popular, there's Tilda Swilton , Peter Dinkalage, Sergio Castellitto is very popular in Italy, Simon Pegg, they also had Bill Nighy for a while.

I like it when they have popular actors it helps them get more attention.

Do you think Brooke Shields would be a good choice? She is very pretty, plus a good actress, and she recently showed she can play a villain on a TV Halloween movie.

~Riella

Brooke Shields
Pretty - Yes
Good Actress - Yes
Too Old - Yes

I believe the LotGK needs to be younger than her early thirties....because she had to be a reasonable age to seduce Rilian who is in yes early twenties (I believe).

LotGK does not need to be seducing. She is not a seductress. She enchants him against his will. He is not being seduced to be there.

Anyways, my #1 pick for LotGK is Helena Bonham Carter. I think she's perfect. She really is quite pretty yet at the same time, has some witch-y features.

Um you are mistaken. Remember how Lewis described how in awe Rillian was of the Lady of the Green Kirtle? How he looked like a man out of his wits.

Rillian was seduced to an extent by the Lady of the Green Kirtle. I don't think the seduction (before the kidnapping) was overly sexual, but his attraction to her physically was apparent.

My guess is that Rillain was lured away by the Lady of the Green Kirtle by both seduction and enchantment. I believe it was only after he found himself getting strapped down to a chair in the Underworld that he began to realise that the Lady may not be the woman for him.

Um you are mistaken. Remember how Lewis described how in awe Rillian was of the Lady of the Green Kirtle? How he looked like a man out of his wits.
Rillian was seduced to an extent by the Lady of the Green Kirtle. I don't think the seduction (before the kidnapping) was overly sexual, but his attraction to her physically was apparent.
My guess is that Rillain was lured away by the Lady of the Green Kirtle by both seduction and enchantment. I believe it was only after he found himself getting strapped down to a chair in the Underworld that he began to realise that the Lady may not be the woman for him.

Well said Josh. I was contemplating how to word what I was thinking.....but you did it perfectly for me.

i am very excited for their interpretation of the LofGK. I like what they did with the WW so I am trusting them to do something awesome.

I hope they market the witch aspect heavily for SC......but accurately (like in LWW, not VDT....I think the WW had as much screen time in the trailer as she did in the actual movie of VDT. LOL!). I think a strong female villan worked well in LWW and I think it has the potential to do again in the SC.