Bailee Madison (she is so adorable) if only she had blond hair and was British. ( I am pretty strict about wanting them British.) I would have to go with Molly Windsor as the best Polly so far.

I think for Polly, I´d still go for a blond and maybe hazel/blue eyes..

what about this girl?

Tory Green. A born performer, Tory started singing and acting at the age of 5, and by age 8 had sung the national anthem in front of 22,000 people at a Dallas Stars hockey game. Tory has acted in several commercials, and as a member of Barney’s Colorful World stage tour, she traveled across the United States and into Canada, Mexico, and Puerto Rico, performing seven shows a week for over a year. Born in Melbourne, Australia, Tory now lives in Los Angeles, California, with her parents and older brother and sister.

she might be a bit too old now though...

what about this girl?

Tory Green. A born performer, Tory started singing and acting at the age of 5, and by age 8 had sung the national anthem in front of 22,000 people at a Dallas Stars hockey game. Tory has acted in several commercials, and as a member of Barney’s Colorful World stage tour, she traveled across the United States and into Canada, Mexico, and Puerto Rico, performing seven shows a week for over a year. Born in Melbourne, Australia, Tory now lives in Los Angeles, California, with her parents and older brother and sister.

she might be a bit too old now though...

I just looked her up, she is 17, so she is to old for that part.
I imagned Polly how Pauline drew her, long blonde hair, blue eyes, kinda short.
but I always thought she was 9, I can't think of her being older!

True, I'm re-reading that book right now, and it says when Polly saw the green ring, if she had been a bit younger she would have sucked on it. lol so...I'm guessing she's pretty young. Maybe 10 at the oldest.

You make a good point. I agree with you there. She is definitely not as old as Jill when she goes to Narnia.

I think Polly should have blonde or dirty blonde hair and should be in between the ages of 13-15 because I think that is where you start to find really talented actresses. The ages below that are a little too young and it is hard to find good talent that young . I wish the casting directors would look internationally instead of just in Europe...

I think Lewis' timeline said that Polly and Digory were 11-12. I'm guessing that means Digory was 12 and Polly was 11. But I'm flexible about ages.

Is anyone else familiar with Maisie Williams? She plays Arya Stark in a Game of Thrones, and if you ask me, she's a pretty good actress.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm3586035/

At first glance, Arya Stark looks like she could make a great Polly. Polly's appearance has been the most shadowy in my mind, since I never was quite sure how I pictured her. I will say that due to Pauline Baynes's illustrations, I pictured her with light hair, but that's not set in stone. At this point, I'm open to anyone. Arya Stark is definitely a good suggestion, ChristProclamer.