I love molly's looks too! Innocent like I imagined her!

Rosie looks like a good Polly too the only thing is that I imagine her hair a lighter blonde.

I like Rosie (in the picture with the lighter, curly hair). Nice for an older (like 12 maybe) Polly instead of a younger (like 9). I think 12 works for the story; she's definitely not a woman yet ans still very much little girl (I think she's sort of Tom-boyish, actually) but she is old enough to be brave and audiences can relate for to her than if she was younger.

Lu

Like most of you here I have always imagined Polly with blond hair (more wavy instead of curly) and green or blue eyes. However I wouldn't be too worried if they cast someone who didn't have those exact traits. After all there is the makeup and hair crew. I think Molly Windsor looks great for the part, but I haven't seen her films or anything.
They should also consider somone who will interact well with the actor they cast as Diggory.

I think the girl from True Grit would make a perfect Polly!

Hailie Steinfeld?! Shes more of a Jill too me, but she is a great actress so I see where you're comming from!

I personally loved Hailee Steinfeld, but I think she might be a little to mature-looking and a little too American. She's a brilliant actress, but come on, she's from California. Polly is from London. Major-big difference.

I wonder, will they hold open casting calls (like how they cast the Pevensies) or will kids have to get agents (as how they cast Will P. as Eustace)?

Charlotte, I actually thought of her for Jill at first too! Too bad they're not making Silver Chair next

ChristProclamer, hmm that is a good point, I seem to remember hearing William Mosley saying you had to be British to be in the movies.

I have always thought of Polly as a nine or ten year old, and kind of slim with dark brown curly hair.

I like Molly Windsor, but I think her hair should be dyed and curled.

i completly agree polly needs ribon. but the actress who is eventually cast doesnt need curls because you could always use tongs but i think blue/grey eyes blond / light brown hair quite mature for her age and haer body should be curvy and not fat but not thin.I would say ten to 13 age wise unless the actress looks really young like Will Poulter.

i am sorry but i just cant imagen andria as polly ,polly was never a brunet for me.

Right now, what I have in mind is a blond haired girl, doesn´t really matter the eye color, cause they can use contact lenses, also, they can choose the americans ( but with a london look ) that can do a really really really good accent. Age... 10 to 13 I´d say...

I really REALLY think Rosie Taylor-Ritson is a great Polly!

I do think that they (if they even used her) should dye her hair reddish-brown, and curl it.

~DP Dessa

perfect jill pole what on earth do you mean by "a london look"

I wonder, will they hold open casting calls (like how they cast the Pevensies) or will kids have to get agents (as how they cast Will P. as Eustace)?

They will use agencies. The big search for the Pevensies won't be repeated - that was special.

Right now, what I have in mind is a blond haired girl, doesn´t really matter the eye color, cause they can use contact lenses, also, they can choose the americans ( but with a london look ) that can do a really really really good accent. Age... 10 to 13 I´d say...

There may not be any such person. At 10 to 13 most children speak the way people around them do. Around people with a different accent they tend to emphasize their own idioms. To speak like a Londoner you have to live there.

I think these are all great ideas!
But does no-one else envision polly as having red hair?

I think it would be amazing if Polly had really long, curly red hair, it would totally add to her character. She is seen as being very polite and proper but she is confident and becomes really adventurous in Narnia.

Also I think Polly should be older than 11 or 12. In the old illustrated books of "The Magician's Nephew" Polly is quite tall and looks quite mature. Maybe 15 or 16 years?

So, a little older with red hair and really blue, inquisitive eyes. Does no-one else think this sort of description qould make a brilliant Polly??!

Just an idea...