I think they'll keep Tilda, and I would like them too. I loved her as the white which, didn't like her in VDT, but other than that I would that they keep her

I Think they should and will keep Tilda. I think that it would be less confusing for most non-book fans. As well it would require less money (if they had to recast Jadis and pay two actresses-one for Jadis and then another for morphing her into Tilda.)

I think they should keep Tilda. She is a wonderful actress, and as Valiant said, it will be less confusing for those who have not read the book. I honestly can't picture anyone else playing that role.

What kind of changes are they going to make to her to show the difference between Jadis and the White Witch?

Hmmmm..... I'm not sure I quite caught the difference between Jadis and the WW. I always thought they were the same. I just recently reread the book and guess I probably will need to again.

I want Tilda back, there's no question about that for me.

I think filmmakers have a pretty cool opportunity in this movie with Tilda being a few years older than when she filmed LWW. When she eats the Apple, why not make her appear younger again? After all, it is the apple of youth. Makes sense to me anyways.

As far as other changes. The one change the book describes is that her skin turns as white as salt. Ironically, the filmmakers chose to make Tilda very pale in LWW rather than white, so it will be interesting to see what they do here.

Along the same lines, most people envision the White Witch/Jadis as having black hair (compliments of Pauline Baynes... she's never described that way in the books) and the filmmakers made her sort of blonde in the movie. Perhaps her hair could have the same effect as her skin? Black until she eats the apple and then her hair changes as well? Just a thought.

That is exactly what I was thinking in terms of appearance change, Fantasia_Kitty. I'm not sure how good Tilda would look with black hair, but I at least hope they won't give her those dredlocks again. I'd like to see her with a little colour before eating the apple. And I think that as she's just Jadis, not yet the White Witch, a costume change is in order. Different cut, different colour, different fabrics...I always pictured Charn as a very colourful, alien place, and I'd like to see her costume reflect that.

Yeah...she should definitely lose the dreds. *wince*

As for Tilda herself...I had always been in favour of a recast personally, but I see that a lot of people overrule me. I just can't see Digory and Andrew ogling Tilda Swinton's Jadis all throughout the film as they do in the book; the relationships will just have to be altered if (or when) they keep her.

I say keep Tilda Swinton, but make her tan and give her red hair; then when she eats the apple, she turns pale and her hair turns that light reddish blond.

Before the movies came out, I actually envisioned Jadis as Brazilian. And Charn would have been kind of like the Aztec empire, with pyramids and such. When she ate the apple her lips were stained red by the apple and her skin turned white. I was bummed that they chose a very white person instead of digitalizing her color (although I must admit I really loved Tilda's interpretation). So while I hope for the sake of consistency that they use Tilda, I think that I'd be ok with them using a younger, prettier actress for her Charn self. In fact, that's a pretty good idea. Don't put Tilda into the poster, don't put her into the trailer; surprise the movie-goers with the transformation at the end! I think that would be cool actually, brilliant thinking Valiant.

Shy Galadriel, I doubt that they will hide Tilda Swinton if they use her as only she and Aslan are the common links for Narnia fans, and they will want to plaster their faces everywhere and in every trailer so that the fans come out to see it. They will probably use Tilda Swinton to get LWW fans to say 'look! the lady from the first one!'. Of course this is an assumption but I think that's what they'll do. Plus I think they will use Tilda Swinton as she has seemingly been champing at the bit to get to be the White Witch again.

This is just my thoughts/opinions of course.

Lu

^^ I know! Groan [facepaw] But saying it at least helps to get our opinion out, that perhaps having Tilda in an awesome cameo is better than plastering her face all over the posters then giving her a crummy part in the film. The people who see her on the poster will say, "Oh look! It's that lady from the first one! And the second one! And the third one! Boy I thought she died in the first, won't they get rid of her? I guess that they just want to milk her character for all she's worth!"
That's why I think they SHOULDN'T use her face even WHEN they use her. The reasoning is so the people who see the poster think one of two things, "Hey, they decided not to milk that character anymore!"; or "Hey, they must have run out of money to use that actress anymore." In the first case, they would go see the movie and see her in her second legitimate Narnia appearance. In the second, they might not go to see the film because who wants to see a washed-up sequel/prequel that can't hire good actors anymore? But they hear from other people later that it's an amazing movie and go see it the second or third week. Then they tell their friends, who tell their friends, who tell their friends, UNTIL ALL THE WORLD WATCHES THE MAGICIAN'S NEPHEW!!! Excuse my enthusiasm.

^lol! Yeah, I see what you mean...if they had only left WW dead!

LWW: Awesome! Tilda Swinton did a great WW! Really scary, and her and Edmund...aw, that was a great movie! And then when Aslan kills her...

PC: What?? In the book they didn't actually- oh well, nice touch. Edmund saved the day. Cool.

VDT: What?? 'go away, you're dead'???? Come on, guys!!

SC: 'Hi, I am Tilda Swinton, the WW AND the Emerald Witch, too. Fear me! The Witch that never really died even though the first movie is all about how Aslan defeated me....MUHAHAHAHAHAHA!!

I agree, Shy Galadriel! I agree...

Lu

Shy Galadriel, I really love your idea of hiding the fact that Jadis is the WW. That would be fantastic and really suprising to those who haven't read the film. But I am sure they will include her in trailers and posters and every piece of marketing as much as they can. In fact, I'm sure they will over do it. I mean if they included her so much in VDT marketing when she only appeared for 10 seconds, how much more will they use her when she actutally has a significant role in the film.

Yeah, if she's in it for two minutes all of her two minutes will be in the trailer, and the last 15 seconds will be about Digory, Polly and Uncle Andrew!

It's already proven fact that Tilda is still going to be Jadis. It's one of the reasons why they are doing MN first then SC because Tilda wants to finish up her part and MN is the film she was really looking forward to all along. So yeah she's still Jadis.